NJDEP
has been interested in sources of emissions of air toxic compounds,
especially area sources such as . wastewater treatment facilities. NJDEP
was also interested in further defining the air quality for the southern
industrialized areas in the city of Camden. This pilot project study
was conducted as part of NJDEP efforts to obtain information concerning
the sources of air toxic compounds in the Camden general area, to supplement
neighborhood "bucket brigade" sampling recently instituted
in the area, and to demonstrate the use of Open-Path Fourier Transform
Infrared technology (OP-FTIR) in obtaining air toxic emission rates
from local sources. A major potential contributor to ambient air levels
of certain chemicals in the project area is the Camden County Municipal
Utitilities Authority (CCMUA) wastewater treatment facility (WWTF),
which includes many area sources that require specialized sampling to
determine emission potential. Use of OP-FTIR for air emissions assessment
was suggested from results of a former study conducted at the Joint
Meeting WWTF. Further evaluation of the technique for air toxics measurement
and emission rate assessment was incorporated for the present study.
NJDEP and local community issues related to odor control and odorous
compound sampling prompted alteration of the initially designed program
to include some refined additional air sampling methods for these types
of components.
“Air
Toxics Measurement within Camden, NJ and A Demonstration of Emission
Rate Determination Using OP-FTIR and Path-averaged SUMMA® Canisters”
PROJECT
DESCRIPTION
The focus of the study was to utilize new tools to better characterize
air toxic compounds from a complex fugitive emission source. To further
field test this emerging technology, the area of Camden Waterfront South
was considered as concerns of fugitive air emissions were noted in early
meetings for the air toxics risk reduction pilot project being conducted
there. This methods development research project was conducted as a
preliminary effort to obtain improved information for potential sources
of air toxic compounds in Camden South Waterfront area, and to supplement
neighborhood "bucket brigade" sampling recently instituted
there. A major potential source in the project area, the Camden County
Municipal Utilities Authority (CCMUA), which includes many area sources,
such as open tanks and waste material handling operations, requiring
specialized sampling to determine emission potential was selected for
the study. The CCMUA is a regional wastewater treatment facility that
treats approximately 60 million gallons of wastewater from approximately
37 municipalities, representing a mix of residential, commercial and
industrial input.
This
study provides an approach to compiling data on potential area sources
of a number of chemicals, including Volatile Organic Compounds (VOCs)
[hydrocarbon, oxygenated compounds, aromatics, and chlorinated compounds]
and ammonia, demonstrating use of Open Path-Fourier Transform Infrared
(OP-FTIR) instrumentation, in conjunction with standard air sampling
methods. The OP-FTIR has real-time analysis capabilities and can measure
pollutants across an open space, such as the top of a tank. A beam of
infrared light is sent across the open tank, or along a path upwind
or downwind of a potential emission source, to a reflector. This light-beam
is then reflected back to the instrument; molecules of chemicals intercepted
in the beam path uniquely absorb energy allowing analysis of the resulting
absorption spectrum to identify and quantify the molecules present.
The
main scope of the project was a demonstration program using OP-FTIR
technology in conjunction with path-averaged SUMMA® (stainless steel
evacuated canister) sampling methods data, with one unit or operation
source at CCMUA to be selected as the highest emission source to generate
air toxic emission rate data for the source. SUMMA® canisters were
employed for collection of air toxic components and selected VOCs as
listed in the EPA TO-14 method. Modifications to the original scope
of work added a limited odor-producing chemical characterization effort.
Specially-coated SUMMA® canisters allowed for desorption of sulfur
compounds and analysis by Gas Chromatography/Mass Spectrometry (GC/MS)
for selected reduced sulfur compounds [methyl mercaptan, carbonyl sulfide,
dimethyl sulfide, dimethyl disulfide, and carbon disulfide] and hydrogen
sulfide. The canisters were also be analyzed for selected aldehydes
using GC/MS.
Limited
neighborhood samples were collected at several downwind locations in
coordination with simultaneous NJDEP Bucket Brigade sampling. The project
results provided additional information to improve future targeted sampling
and analysis efforts, increase our knowledge of chemicals observed in
the area, and will assist wastewater treatment facilities in refining
odor-related chemical measurements and possibly in better targeting
operational and/or control modifications for consideration.
PROJECT OBJECTIVES
1. Determine WWTF area sources compound identification and relative
concentrations by applying path averaged coated SUMMA® Summa canister
data collection for identified area sources at the facility as well
as for upwind backgrounds for this facility in a preliminary sampling.
2.
Provide a database identifying and quantifying air toxic compounds for
the highest emitting WWTF sources consisting of OP-FTIR data and path
averaged SUMMA® canister data.
3.
Demonstrate the emission rate determination process for the suspected
highest emitting source using OP-FTIR and supplementary SUMMA® canister
data.
4.
Assess the feasibility of extending emission rate determination to other
WWTF area sources and other area sources that NJDEP may have an interest
in.
The
study was composed of two phases. The first phase included SUMMA®
canister sampling in order to obtain preliminary information of background
levels and on-site sources with respect to air toxics and certain odorous
compounds.
During
the preliminary phase, only acetone and toluene were observed at somewhat
elevated levels outdoors. Indoor area sampling observed higher levels
of these compounds and methyl ethyl ketone. Measurable levels of sulfur
compounds were rarely observed, even inside process and storage buildings.
The
second, or follow-up sampling phase, further employed the use of the
Open Path-Fourier Transform Infrared (OP-FTIR) instrumentation. During
this second sampling phase, more intense sampling was performed at targeted
on-site locations (selected from the results of the phase one effort).
In this second phase of the study, some ammonia was observed in ambient
air. In addition, there were also very small quantities of potentially
odorous compounds, such as methylthioformamide. Concentrations of toxic
organic compounds continued to be quite low.
Overall,
it should be noted that although OP-FTIR is unique in allowing for detection
of a wide range of chemicals and allows for use over a large surface
area source, the limits of detection for specific compounds may be somewhat
high. Additional refinement of the methods used with this equipment
will be necessary prior to routine use in monitoring air around complex
facilities. However, the method does demonstrate promise when combined
with SUMMA® canister sampling. The canister sampling does enhance
the detection capabilities of such projects, but again, in the case
of reduced-sulfur compounds, the detection limits of the method are
important to be aware of.
The
course of this project, the project team was able to provide suggestions
for improved operations and to point out to CCMUA some areas where odor
control strategies might be most effective. Additional funding is currently
being sought for projects to address enhanced reduced-sulfur air monitoring
at lower detection limits and more chemical specific methods for licorice-root
processing facilities, such as the neighboring MAFCO facility.
Disclaimer:
Mention of trade names or commercial products does not constitute endorsement
or recommendation for use.