The State of New Jersey
NJ Department of Banking and Insurance
search  

Home > Consumer Information > Insurance Topics > Homeowner > Contact Information - Homeowners Insurers in New Jersey
Insurers that Write Homeowners Policies in New Jersey


This list includes all insurance companies that have Homeowners policies in effect in New Jersey. This includes owners, renters/tenants, and condos.

In addition to the list below, the following companies only write Renters/Tenant Policies

Looking for Mobile Homeowners Insurance?



Insurer Telephone Number Direct Writer or Contact Agent
and Web site
21st Century Group
  • 21st Century Pinnacle Insurance Co. (formerly American International Insurance Co. of New Jersey)
1-800-622-2488 Direct
www.21stcentins.com
ACE Group
  • Atlantic Employers Insurance Company
  • Bankers Standard Insurance Company
1-800-352-4462 Agent
www.ace-ina.com

Allstate NJ Insurance Company (not writing new business)

Allstate New Jersey Property & Casualty Insurance Company

908-252-5000 Agent
www.allstate.com
American Commerce Insurance Company 1-800-222-2114 Agent
www.acilink.com
American European Group
  • Rutgers Enhanced Insurance Company
  • Rutgers Casualty Insurance Company
856-779-0600 Agent
www.aeiginsurance.com
American International Group
  • AIG Property Casualty Co.
  • Insurance Company of the State of Pennsylvania
1-800-613-5207

Agent
www.aig.com
American Strategic Insurance Corporation 1-866-274-8765 Agent
www.americanstrategic.com
Amica Mutual Insurance Company 1-800-652-6422 Direct
www.amica.com
Andover Group
  • Merrimack Mutual Fire Insurance Co.
  • Bay State Insurance Co.
  • Cambridge Mutual Fire Insurance Co.
978-475-3300 Agent
www.andovercos.com
Armed Forces Insurance Exchange
(membership company for military personnel)
913-727-5500 Direct
www.afi.org
Assurant Group
  • American Bankers Insurance Co. of Florida
  • American Security Insurance Company (condos only)
1-800-535-1333

1-800-852-2244
Agent
www.assurant.com
 
www.Assurantspecialtyproperty.com
California Casualty & Fire Insurance Company
(membership group for educators, firefighters and nurses)
1-866-680-5143 Direct
www.calcas.com
Chubb Group
  • Chubb Insurance Company of NJ
  • Federal Insurance Company
  • Great Northern Insurance Co.
  • Pacific Indemnity Company
  • Vigilant Insurance Company
908-903-2000 Agent
www.chubb.com
Companion Property & Casualty Insurance Company 1-800-845-2724 Agent
www.companiongroup.com
CSAA Mid-Atlantic Insurance Company of NJ 1-800-542-9544 Direct (CSAA)
www.aaamidatlantic.com
Cumberland Mutual Fire Insurance Company 856-451-4050 Agent
www.cumberlandgroup.com
Electric Insurance Company 1-800-342-5342 Direct
www.electricinsurance.com
Encompass Group
  • Encompass Insurance Company of NJ (not writing new business)
  • Encompass Property and Casualty Insurance Company of New Jersey


1-800-260-1454

1-800-558-7400
(Claims)
Agent
www.encompassinsurance.com
Farm Family Casualty Insurance Company
(membership company for farmers) (not writing new business)

United Farm Family Insurance Company
(membership company for farmers)
518-431-5000 Agent
www.farmfamily.com
Farmers Insurance Co. of Flemington 908-782-4120 Agent
www.FarmersofFlemington.com
Farmers Insurance Group
  • Truck Insurance Exchange
1-800-327-6377 Agent
www.farmers.com
Farmers Mutual Fire Insurance Co. of Salem County 856-935-1851 Agent
www.farmersofsalem.com
Fireman's Fund Group
  • American Insurance Co. (not writing new business)
  • Fireman's Fund Indemnity Corp. (not writing new business)
  • Fireman's Fund Insurance Co. (not writing new business)
  • National Surety Corporation
415-899-2000 Agent
www.firemansfund.com
First American Property Casualty Insurance Co. (not writing condos) 1-888-474-7500 Agent
www.firstam.com
Fitchburg Mutual Insurance Co. 1-800-688-1825 Agent
www.ndgroup.com
FM Global
  • Affiliated FM Insurance Company (membership only for company employees and retirees)
1-800-343-7722 Direct
www.affiliatedFM.com
Foremost Insurance Company Grand Rapids, MI
(not writing new business)
1-800-237-2060 Agent
www.foremost.com
Founders Insurance Company
(Penn National Group)
717-234-4941 Agent
www.pennnationalinsurance.com
Franklin Mutual Group
  • FMI Insurance Co.
  • Fidelity Mohawk Insurance Co. (not writing new business)
  • Franklin Mutual Insurance Co.
973-948-3120 Agent
www.fmiweb.com
Global Liberty Insurance Company of New York 516-576-8181 Agent
www.globallibertyny.com
Hanover Insurance Group
  • Citizens Insurance Co. of America (not writing new business)
  • Hanover Insurance Co. (not writing new business)
  • Massachusetts Bay Insurance Co.
508-853-7200 Agent
www.hanover.com
Harleysville Insurance Company of NJ 215-256-5000 Agent
www.harleysvillegroup.com
Hartford Group
  • Hartford Underwriters Insurance Company
    (membership company for AARP, not writing new business)
  • Property Casualty Insurance Company of Hartford (membership company for AARP, not writing new busines)
  • Trumbull Insurance Company (membership company for AARP)
  • Hartford Fire Insurance Company
1-800-843-7824
(AARP)


1-800-460-9783
(Non-AARP)
Direct
www.aarp.thehartford.com/mypolicy
(AARP)


www.hartfordauto.thehartford.com

(Non-AARP)
Homesite Insurance Co. 1-800-466-3748 Direct
www.homesite.com
Hyundai Marine & Fire Insurance Company, Ltd. 1-855-436-3467 Agent
www.hyundaiinsuranceusa.com
IDS Property Casualty Insurance Co. 1-800-842-3344 Direct
www.ameriprise.com
Integon National Insurance Co. 1-877-883-6599 Agent
www.nationalgeneral.com
Liberty Mutual Group
  • Liberty Mutual Fire Insurance Company (not writing new business)
  • Liberty Mutual Mid-Atlantic Insurance Co.
  • LM Insurance Corporation
1-800-837-5254

1-800-225-2467
(Claims)
Agent
www.libertymutual.com
Mercer Insurance Company of NJ, Inc. 609-737-0426 Agent
www.mercerins.com
Merchants Group
  • Merchants Mutual Insurance Co. (not writing new business)
  • Merchants Preferred Insurance Co. (not writing new business)
716-849-3333 Agent
www.merchantsgroup.com
Mercury Indemnity Company of America 1-800-987-2032 Agent
www.mercuryinsurance.com
Metropolitan Group
  • Metropolitan Group P&C Insurance Co.
  • Metropolitan P&C Insurance Co.
1-800-442-5986 Direct (Metropolitan Group)
Agent (Metropolitan P&C)
www.metlife.com
Narragansett Bay Insurance Company 1-800-343-3375 Agent
www.nbic.com
New Jersey Manufacturers Group
  • NJ Manufacturers Insurance Company
    (membership company for certain affinity groups)
  • NJ Re-Insurance Company (membership company for certain affinity groups; not writing new business)
609-883-1300 Direct
www.njm.com
New Jersey Skylands Insurance Association 1-866-279-7688

1-877-365-8693
(Claims)
Agent
www.njsi.com
Occidental Fire & Casualty Company of North Carolina 1-800-481-0661 Agent
www.occidentalins.com
Pacific Specialty Insurance Company 1-800-303-5000 Agent
www.pacificspecialty.com
Philadelphia Contributionship Group
  • Germantown Insurance Co.
  • Philadelphia Contributionship Insurance
215-627-1752 Agent
www.contributionship.com
Plymouth Rock
  • High Point Preferred Insurance Company (not writing new business)
  • Palisades Property and Casualty Insurance Co.

1-866-INSURANCE

1-877-725-6423

Agent
www.plymouthrocknj.com
Preferred Mutual Insurance Co. 607-847-6161 Agent
www.pminsco.com
Privilege Underwriters Reciprocal Exchange (PURE) 1-888-813-7873 Agent
www.purehnw.com
Providence Mutual Fire Insurance Co. 401-827-1800 Agent
www.providencemutual.com
Public Service Mutual Insurance Co. 1-800-223-5213 Agent
www.psmins.com
QBE Insurance Group
  • Praetorian Insurance Company
  • QBE Insurance Company
1-800-676-5066
1-800-660-4539
Agent
www.qbena.com
Safeco
  • American Fire and Casualty Co. (not writing new business)
  • Ohio Casualty Insurance Co. (not writing new business)
  • West American Insurance Co. (not writing new business)
  • Excelsior Insurance Co.
1-800-542-5385 Agent
www.safeco.com
Selective Insurance Company of America
  • Selective Insurance Co. of America (not writing new business)
  • Selective Casualty Insurance Co. (writing renewal business of Selective Insurance Co. of America)
  • Selective Way Insurance Co. (not writing new business)
  • Selective Fire and Casualty Insurance Co. (writing renewal business of Selective Way Insurance Co.)
  • Selective Auto Insurance Company of New Jersey
973-948-3000

1-800-777-9656
Agent
www.selective.com
State Farm Fire & Casualty Company 973-739-5000 Agent
www.statefarm.com
Stillwater Property and Casualty Insurance Co. (formerly Fidelity National Property and Casualty Insurance Co.) 1-800-849-6140 Agent
www.StillwaterInsurance.com
Tower Group Companies
  • Castlepoint Insurance Company
  • Tower Insurance Company of New York
  • Tower National Insurance Company
  • Preserver Insurance Company (not writing new business)

1-866-422-1366

1-888-856-5522
(Claims)
Agent
www.twrgrp.com
Travelers Group
  • Fidelity & Guaranty Insurance Underwriters, Inc.
1-800-692-6837 Agent
www.travelers.com
United Property & Casualty Insurance Company 1-800-295-8016 Agent
www.upcinsurance.com
Universal North America Insurance Company 1-800-905-7550 Agent
www.uihna.com
USAA Group
(membership group for military personnel)
  • Garrison Property and Casualty Insurance Company
  • USAA Casualty Insurance Company
  • USAA General Indemnity Company
  • United Services Auto Association
1-800-531-8722 Direct
www.usaa.com
Utica First Insurance Company 1-800-456-4556 Agent
www.uticafirst.com
Utica Mutual Group
  • Graphic Arts Mutual Insurance Co. (not writing new business)
  • Utica Mutual Insurance Co. (not writing new business)
315-734-2000 Agent
www.uticamutual.com
Zurich Financial Services
  • Empire Fire and Marine Insurance Co. (not writing new business)
1-800-660-4539 Agent
 
Insurers that Write Tenant Policies in New Jersey

This list includes insurance companies that only write Tenant/Renters policies.

Insurer Telephone Number Direct Writer or Contact Agent
and Web site
American Modern Insurance Group
  • American Family Home Insurance Company
  • American Modern Home Insurance Company
1-800-543-2644 Agent
www.amig.com
Kemper Direct Group
  • Merastar Insurance Company
1-877-481-8836 Direct
www.kemperdirect.com
Markel American Insurance Company 1-800-236-2862 Agent
www.markelamerican.com

 

Insurers that Write Mobile Homeowners Policies in New Jersey

This list includes insurance companies that write Mobile Homeowners policies.

Insurer Telephone Number Direct Writer or Contact Agent
and Web site
Aegis Security Insurance Company 1-800-233-2160 Agent
www.aegisfirst.net
Allstate New Jersey Insurance Company
(renewal business only)
908-252-5000 Agent
www.allstate.com
American Bankers Insurance Co. of Florida 1-800-535-1333 Agent
www.assurant.com
 
American Modern Insurance Group
  • American Family Home Insurance Company
  • American Modern Home Insurance Company
1-800-543-2644 Agent
www.amig.com
Foremost Insurance Group
  • Foremost Insurance Company Grand Rapids
  • Foremost Property & Casualty Insurance Company
1-800-237-2060


1-800-752-2461
Direct and Agent
www.foremost.com


Direct and Agent
www.aarpforemost.com
State Farm Fire & Casualty Company 973-739-5000 Agent
www.statefarm.com


Direct Writer: The industry term for a company that uses its own sales employees to write its policies.

To find an agent in your area,
check your telephone book or call the insurance company and ask for agents near you.

Report changes/errors here


 
OPRA
OPRA is a state law that was enacted to give the public greater access to government records maintained by public agencies in New Jersey.
line
Adobe Acrobat
You will need to download the latest version of Adobe Acrobat Reader in order to correctly view and print PDF (Portable Document Format) files from this web site.
state seal
Copyright © 2011, State of New Jersey
New Jersey Department of Banking and Insurance